Skip to main content
We are here to help:

Evaluating False News and Misinformation

This Research Guide aims to discuss what False News is. It also shares tools and resources for evaluating False News.

Quick Tips for Checking Social Media Posts

undefined

(Shared by Cindy Otis, author of True or False: A CIA Analyst's Guide to Spotting Fake News, at https://twitter.com/CindyOtis_/status/1285722102134341633)

Bot or Not? Evaluating Legitimacy of Social Media Accounts

Check the Profile Photo

  • Be wary of "blank" profiles using the default:
  • Is the account using a "selfie" as an avatar? Use Google Image Search's "Reverse Image Search" or TinEye to see if it has been posted elsewhere.
  • Are they using art other than their picture? Check how it relates to their account activity or bio.

Examine the User Name

  • Is there a series of numbers following the name? Do the numbers start at an odd cut-off point (such as matth8365845 versus matthew8365845)?
    • Note: some users choose to use the default assigned user name.
  • What about superfluous punctuation (i.e., not needed to differentiate from an official vs. an impersonator)? Underscores, dashes, etc.
  • Look even closer; sometimes an upper-case "i" is actually a lower-case "L," or an "n" is actually an "m."
    • Tip: copy/paste into a Word document, then change to a serif font like Times New Roman.

Twitter-Verified Accounts

  • Look for the blue verified badge:
  • It should be next to the name on the account profile, including on posts in your feed and on search results.
  • If it appears anywhere BUT next to the name (photo, background, bio), it is not actually verified!
  • Not all legitimate accounts choose to be verified, but again, beware of those that try to look like it.

Look at their Followers, Following, and Suggested Follows

  • What is their follower/following ratio?
  • WHO do they follow? Is there a disproportionate number of one type?
  • Did they all follow at once?
  • What accounts are they suggesting you follow?
  • Posting habits:
    • Do they tend to auto-tweet a lot of content?
    • Check "Tweets and Replies." Do they comment with commentary, jokes, answers or questions? Or just one-word answers like "nice" or "great?"

Bot Sentinel: This tool analyzes and scores Twitter accounts, ranking them as Normal, Questionable, Disruptive, or Problematic.

"SPOT THE TROLL"

This quiz, created by Clemson University Media Forensics Hub, takes you through eight actual social media profiles...can you spot the troll?

 

How and Why Do Tweets Trend?

Volume combined with time; Twitter's algorithm favors high volume within a short period.

Engagement: when someone clicks anywhere on a tweet, this is measured, and can include retweets, replies, and likes, plus the following:

  • Did someone follow you based on clicking "follow" in your tweet?
  • Did someone click on a link in your tweet?
  • Did they click on a photo or hashtag? Play an embedded video?

Beware of the RATIO! The ratio on Twitter is the comparison of replies, retweets, and likes.

  • Generally a "bad ratio" is 2:1 or more replies to retweets/likes.
  • This is a sign the tweet was controversial and enough people objected to it (and felt strongly enough) to respond.
    • There is no "dislike" option on Twitter, so the only other recourse to register disagreement is to comment/reply to the Tweet.
  • Replies (even negative ones) still = engagement and contribute to trends.

undefined

https://twitter.com/PMourdoukoutas/status/1020654721655242754

(Pssst...this is a BAD ratio!)